A national identity issue and cake
I’ve read a couple of posts recently that piqued my considerable mental prowess and got it ruminating on the issue of a ‘national’ identity, primarily a Sri Lankan identity and what seems to be a never ending quest to find/formulate one. The posts in question included this one addressing labels and purpose and another one entreating Sri Lankans to join hands in preserving ‘traditional’ Sri Lankan music.
The first post I found intriguing in its critique of ‘labeling’ which though I feel is a valid criticism is to me pretty much unavoidable. I need to label people, not just with names but where I met them, their backgrounds, preferences, religious beliefs, etc. This is simply because I need a ‘context’ to the people that I know. To me it’s unrealistic to behave exactly the same with every person I know; knowing their ‘cultural’ backgrounds, personal preferences lets me tailor my behaviour to each person individually. The negligible minoritist made an interesting point about purpose, but it hurts my head to think of anything meaningful to say about that, but it does make for some interesting pondering.
The second post I read I wasn’t too fond off, especially because it seemed to make certain assumptions of what constitutes Sri Lankan culture based purely on the authors personal preferences and exhibited what to me is a somewhat ‘fishbowl’ attitude in a fear of all things ‘foreign.’ What I found even more annoying actually was the condescending view the author had that just because I left Sri Lanka when I was 18 and though being a regular visitor (well more than regular on some occasions) somehow I had given up the authority to discuss Sri Lankan culture. Actually a sentence that I found telling and a little scary was “…as a Sri Lankan, I’d love to request u to come home and spend some time here, see if u can find that old Sinhalese spark u’ve lost.” Funny because nowhere did I make the insinuation that I am Sinhalese and though being Sinhalese is for sure part of being Sri Lankan it doesn’t give me any more ownership over the Sri Lankan identity than anyone else. I in fact could not be bothered responding to the last comment I got in response to mine simply because I see no point in arguing with idiots, especially those with a ‘holier than thou attitude’ but reading the comment did spark a light bulb over my noggin when I thought of it in the context of the minoritist’s post.
Here’s the thing, I think barking up the tree of a “Sri Lankan national identity” is a mistake, especially when it seems to involve pigeonholing people into being Sri Lankan. I mean what makes a Sri Lankan, our ancestors landing here 2000 years ago from North India, coming in with the invading armies of Elara, evolving in Balangoda, coming to trade with the Arabs or being brought as slave labour by the British. There are so many people who do not fit into the traditional pigeonholes that have contributed so much to Sri Lanka in both traditional and non-traditional fields.
Are we to discount Bawa’s contributions to Sri Lanka’s evolving architectural heritage either because he was a burgher or because he spent time abroad being exposed to (shock, horror, gasp) foreign influences? Are we to turn our back on Arthur C. Clarke’s achievements and contribution to Sri Lanka’s literary and technical development just because he wasn’t born in Sri Lanka? Or similarly Romesh Gunasekera or David Blacker simply because they spent or spend significant time away from Sri Lanka or don’t fit what the ‘traditional’ pigeonhole of what being a Sri Lankan is?
I say fuck national identity. It’s enough being concerned enough about Sri Lanka to write, sing, take photographs, and think about Sri Lankan matters and issues. It’s enough to feel it in your bones that you are Sri Lankan. Who gives a shit where you’re from, what your genetic makeup is or any other of those insignificant little things that make us who we are on the exterior. I think we should be looking for a policy of acceptance, of people of all origin, colour, race, sexual orientation, etc, as long as they are proud of some part of them being Sri Lankan.
P.S. If you like my ideas I might run for presidency in 2015, vote for me and I shall give you not bread but cake for five rupees a pound…and not just any cake, chocolate fudge cake…

“It’s enough to feel it in your bones that you are Sri Lankan” - Amen to that! I wasn’t born in Sri Lanka and I’ve only spent 12 of my 23 years in my Motherland…but that’s still what I consider her - my Motherland. A person can spend one day in a country and feel more at ‘home’ there than a person who has lived there all their life. It has nothing to do with where they’re from originally.
5 bucks for a pound of chocolate fudge cake? you’ve got my vote!
Comment by PseudoRandom — February 25, 2007 @ 11:45 pm
I couldn’t agree with you more. Either you feel it inside or you don’t and I really cannot STAND the types that go on and on about how leaving SL makes you lose your roots/cultural heritage etc. Part of the reason I am GLAD to be away is because of national-minded fishbowling stuck-in-a-well fuckwits like them. In my opinion, those preachy types are exactly what ruin Sri Lanka for me.
They’re very quick to make assumptions too, and most of the time, the assumptions they make about me are completely wrong. So I guess that’s why I never blog about SL issues (really, it’s an open invitation for every opinionated aforementioned fuckwit to share their 2cents) and that’s why I never comment on posts like the ones you linked either. Like you say, I don’t have the energy to argue with idiots.
Comment by Darwin — February 26, 2007 @ 8:36 am
wud b curious 2 go thru ur manifesto “CO25 Chinthana ??” and what wud b ur Logo ?? heh heh
Comment by dogfight — February 26, 2007 @ 10:29 am
can’t u run for president sooner than 2015?? that cake looks divine
Comment by savi3 — February 26, 2007 @ 10:44 am
Does this “idiot” have the permission to comment here?
If no, just delete this.
Since you have generated a very soothing post here and that you seem to have the concurrence of most other (probably Sri Lankans who are away from home) guys, let me just add some more thoughts on what we’ve been arguing so far. By no means is this retaliation or any other weapon to rage a battle with u. Just take it in good spirit, Please…
I hope you won’t mind me writing just one or two lines about me, just to provide you with the proof that I’m not being “Pigeonholed” or “Fish bowled”. I studied in Ananda College Colombo, did my A/L’s and got in to the university (just like any other regular student in Sri Lanka would try to do; Is this my choice? Well that’s a separate issue). And while I was on course for it I received a scholarship to Drexel University, Pennsylvania, USA to study Computer Engineering. But I stayed. May be it was fear that struck me that I might loose everything I cherish here if I’m to go away. Not the bravest thought, I know. So that’s me (not blowing my own trumpet but just so that now you know a bit about me)
I admit; I may be overly proud about being Sri Lankan. I was brought up in such an environment. But by no means have I become narrow minded or partial to a single course of preference and I always always admire the freedom a person should have over his choices and I firmly believe that there should be absolutely no undue influence over them by any other person or party.
I just the get the feeling that the point I wanted to convey through my post has not been grasped by others the way I wanted. May be my “kadda” is not sophisticated enough, after all I’m Sinhalese. But it’s true that I’ve unleashed a bit of anger in my replies to your posts since you came hard on me at the beginning. And I admit that I’ve judged you to be Sinhalese at the beginning (btw, would u mind telling me what nationality u r? Or is it the case you don’t like to be “labeled”?). Anyway, now we are in talking terms (I hope we are) I’ll just add something to what I’ve been trying to say so hard. I won’t comment on the whole “labeling” thing, just on the topic I’ve made you do some “interesting pondering”.
Ok, my single, main question is, Are we to let our classical music die away at the interest of emerging artists (I won’t hurt your feelings so I’ll stop calling them “Overnight” artists for the moment)? Now your obvious question is, I know, what does this bugger mean by “classical”?
I mean the culture of songs before and after the independence (I’m talking about Sinhalese music since I can’t talk about something I don’t know; so I can’t talk about the songs in other languages). I’m talking about the Sinhalese folk songs, the stage drama songs, the “Jana kavi”, the film songs and pretty much every Sinhala song before Bathiya and Santhush era, encapsulating Amaradewa to Victor and M.S to Clarence. I’m sure that you’ll argue that these are contrasting styles, how would anyone say that these are truly Sri Lankan. As you’ve put it once, Amaradewa studied Indian music and M.S mostly did Baila; the Portuguese music style. But there’s a key difference in these compared to those that come out today by fresh artists. That’s quality. Where do you think quality lies in today’s music by the Sri Lankan young generation? Once again, I’m not grouping everyone, but most.
I have a nice question for you. What does content mean to you in a song? Is it the case that you can enjoy a song with a nice enough melody and a bunch of words which has absolutely no meaning and even sometimes makes you revise your language as well? Would you still listen to that song and actually brand it in the “song” category. Well, I’m sorry mate, I can’t; once again a personal preference ha?
Brother (or sister, I don’t know; which one are you again?), just find me some way so that I can send you some mp3s of these latest songs that have been out in the market here at home. I’m telling you man, they are not songs. No matter what we preach about the freedom of choice, these should not be given to the public. Oh and there’s this new caliber of songs here in Sri Lanka by some male artists which seem to kill the masculinity of the people who hear them. They always go like “I can’t do this”, “I can’t do that”, “I can’t get it up”, “Please let me touch your feet”, I mean, how manly are they? (oh by the way, I’m not against homosexuality, so if they are directed to them, then no problem). But the problem is that these songs and the “mal sindu” in particular, are MADE to hear to the public. That’s what these cassette producers do. They distribute these cassettes freely to the general transportation services so that they can forcefully make people listen to them. My stressing of this point may not convince you; that’s why I asked you should come here and listen for a while.
Ok, since you had given some really good points about our identity from how the history evolved through various influences from vijaya to arabs and from british to balangoda I feel a little lost at finding my own “real” identity. But I like to see it as the values with which I’ve grown up, the people I’ve been brought up with and the society I currently struggle to live in. So let’s just leave the identity aside for a while.
Would you at least agree that our classicals and oldies are being dragged into oblivion by the private media channels? Still no? Do you think it’s fair to broadcast only the latest arrivals and let the others die away through time? And do you think it’s fair to steel the tunes of oldies (Not the way Amaradewa used the Indian Raghas or the way MS used the kapiringha style) simply for the purpose of making a remixed hit out of a song that’s already familiar in the peoples’ minds?
After all, now I feel that it’s hard to change the mindset of people (but hey, Sri Lanakn RJs are doing a great job at that). This goes for me and for you as well. Now I believe that people measure things according to the surrounding they dwell in. This is pretty much the lesson I’ve learnt so far by reading and writing about this issue.
You don’t have to reply to this. I just wanted myself to be heard again. But anyway I really really appreciate your comments on my posts. Opens up a different conversation for me.
Thanx, TC
Comment by Niro — February 26, 2007 @ 7:02 pm
Please Check this URL I’d really appreciate it.
Comment by niro — February 26, 2007 @ 7:19 pm
Please check my comments page on the aforementioned post on Sri Lankan traditional music. I’ve posted something for you there.
Comment by niro — February 26, 2007 @ 7:23 pm
now i know what a troll does
Comment by savi3 — February 27, 2007 @ 1:34 pm
What’s that saying…devil finds work for idle….
Comment by Darwin — February 27, 2007 @ 1:47 pm
Pseudorandom – yes! Now only nine million, nine hundred and ninety thousand or so to go. It’s the same with people and countries isn’t it, one can feel more comfortable with someone after one day more than people you’ve known your whole life. I’m glad you feel Sri Lanka in your bones!
Darwin – hehe…idle hands…you talking about me or Niro? But yes some people are far too quick to make assumptions without evidence and you know what they say, assumption is the mother of all fuck-ups
Oh yeah just to clarify I found negligible minoritist interesting, the idiot was the latter…just to avoid any confusion
Dogfight – not sure about the manifesto mate, all I have is the cake so far, and maybe Old Reserve as the national drink and Superblende as the national chocolate. I was actually thinking of a gecko as my logo, why? I dunno…just have a fascination for them
Savi3 – considering the hazards of running for SL presidency I would like to enjoy life just a teeny, weeney bit more!
Niro – all idiots are welcome, just no personal potshots at me or my commentators! Mind you I only tagged you as one because you made assumptions about me losing my Sri Lankan identity just because I don’t live in Sri Lanka. On that note if you’re really that scared about losing your roots because you have the opportunity to live in a foreign land for a bit, you might want to look into that…looks like ur not as comfortable with ur roots as the rest of us.
Also mate please keep to the subject, this post is about national identity NOT about your personal taste in music or mine for that matter.
Savi3 – don’t think he’s a troll….just a fishbowl (maybe I should take up poetry)
Comment by childof25 — February 27, 2007 @ 7:46 pm
Chocolate fudge?? I bet there’ll be hash or weed in it
Comment by Evil Lankan — March 1, 2007 @ 1:15 pm
nope…thats you guys…I don’t do that anymore
Comment by childof25 — March 1, 2007 @ 4:53 pm
weed and cake for 5 bucks.. dude u should be president NOW !!
Comment by savi3 — March 2, 2007 @ 2:31 pm